Car Buying FAQ
Plain-language answers to the 20 most common car buying questions: fees, recalls, VINs, negotiation, EVs, and financing.
Last reviewed . State figures come from the sourced state dataset. How we check the data.
Out-the-Door Price & Fees
What is an out-the-door price?
The out-the-door (OTD) price is the total amount you actually pay to drive a vehicle home. It includes the vehicle price, state sales tax, title fee, registration, plate fees, and dealer doc fee. It does not include ongoing costs like insurance or maintenance. Always negotiate based on the OTD price, not the monthly payment.
What dealer fees are mandatory vs. negotiable?
Mandatory (paid to the government): sales tax, title fee, registration, and plate fees. These are fixed and non-negotiable. Negotiable or refusable: documentation fee (13 states have a dollar cap we could confirm), dealer add-ons like paint sealant or nitrogen tires, VIN etching, market adjustment markups, and extended warranties. Never pay for dealer-installed add-ons you didn't ask for.
How much over MSRP is the actual out-the-door price?
It depends on your state's tax rate and fees. On a $35,000 used vehicle in California, the OTD calculator estimates $2,537.50 in state sales tax plus $204 in doc and DMV fees, for an OTD of $37,742 before local district taxes, which add more in many areas.
Can I negotiate the doc fee?
Sometimes. In states with a doc fee cap (for example Michigan: $280, Maryland: $800), the fee is fixed by law at that ceiling — dealers won't go lower, but at least you know the max. In states with no cap, the doc fee is fully negotiable. Dealers rarely lower it on request, but you can insist on a lower OTD total that nets the same result.
Which states cap dealer doc fees?
OTDCheck has confirmed a dollar cap on the dealer doc fee on an official state page in 13 states: Arkansas ($129), Iowa ($180), Louisiana ($436), Maryland ($800), Michigan ($280), Minnesota ($350), Mississippi ($425), Missouri ($620.79), New York ($175), Oregon ($250), Pennsylvania ($490), Rhode Island ($400) and Washington ($200). Illinois and Ohio cap the fee by law, but we could not confirm the current amount. Indiana, South Carolina and Texas set an amount a dealer may charge without state review, which is not a cap. 13 states set no limit. The other 20 jurisdictions are listed as not verified: we found no official statement either way.
What is a buyer's order?
A buyer's order is the dealer's written summary of a car deal before the final contract: the vehicle, its price, every fee and add-on, the taxes, your trade-in and the total. It is the document to read line by line, because anything on it ends up in the contract you sign.
Recalls & Vehicle Safety
Can a dealer legally sell a used car with an open recall?
Yes, for used cars. Federal law (49 U.S.C. 30120(i)) stops a dealer from selling a new vehicle with an unrepaired safety recall, and it covers rental cars. It does not cover used car sales, so a dealer can sell a pre-owned vehicle with an open NHTSA recall without repairing it. Check every used car's VIN before purchase.
Are recall repairs free?
Yes, always. Manufacturers are legally required to repair safety recalls at no cost to the owner, regardless of when you bought the vehicle or how many owners it's had. Contact the manufacturer or any franchised dealer for that brand. Recall repairs have no expiration date.
How do I check if a car has open recalls before buying?
Enter the 17-character VIN at OTDCheck or NHTSA's official recall database (nhtsa.gov/recalls). The VIN is on the driver-side dashboard corner (visible through the windshield), the door jamb sticker, or your insurance card. Never finalize a used car purchase without checking recalls first.
VIN & Vehicle History
What does a VIN number tell you?
A VIN (Vehicle Identification Number) is a 17-character code that identifies a specific vehicle. It encodes the country of manufacture, maker, vehicle type, model year, assembly plant, and production sequence. By querying databases tied to the VIN, you can find price history, open recalls, title brands, reported accidents, and days on the dealer's lot.
Is OTDCheck's VIN check free?
Yes. The VIN check at otdcheck.com/vin is completely free with no account required. It decodes the vehicle and checks it for open NHTSA safety recalls. The VIN decoder at /tools/vin-decoder is also free and uses NHTSA's official vPIC database.
What is a title brand and why does it matter?
A title brand is a permanent government record attached to a vehicle's title when it has been in a major accident, declared a total loss (salvage), flooded, or had its odometer altered. A branded title significantly reduces resale value: typically 20–50% below clean-title market value. Always check the title status before buying used.
Negotiation & Deal Quality
What is a fair price to pay for a used car?
A fair price is at or below the average price for comparable vehicles (same make, model, year, trim, and mileage) currently listed by dealers in your region. Compare at least three listings for the same model, then upload the dealer's quote to OTD Shield to catch fees and add-ons that push the out-the-door price above what you agreed.
What is a dealer 'market adjustment' and should I pay it?
A market adjustment (also called ADM — Additional Dealer Markup) is an amount a dealer adds to MSRP on top of the sticker price for high-demand vehicles. It is pure profit for the dealer, not a manufacturer or government charge. On any vehicle not in acute shortage, you should refuse it and walk away if the dealer won't remove it. Search other dealers — someone will sell at MSRP.
Should I tell the dealer I'm paying cash?
Not until after you've agreed on the vehicle price. Dealers make money on financing (through rate markups). If they know you're paying cash, they may be less willing to negotiate on price because they lose the finance profit. Agree on the OTD price first, then reveal your payment method.
How many days on lot is too many?
A vehicle sitting more than 45 days is typically a motivated seller. Over 60 days is a strong negotiation lever — dealers pay interest (floor plan financing) on unsold inventory and want it gone. If the listing shows how long the car has been for sale, use that number in your offer.
Trade-Ins & Financing
Should I trade in my car at the dealer or sell it privately?
Selling privately typically gets you 10–20% more than a dealer trade-in. However, trade-ins reduce your taxable amount in most states — in a 9% tax state, a $10,000 trade-in saves $900 in sales tax, partially closing the gap. Evaluate both: get a written dealer offer (Carmax is a reliable benchmark), then decide if the private-sale premium is worth the effort.
What is a good interest rate for a car loan in 2026?
In 2026, average new-car loan rates range from 6–8% for buyers with excellent credit (750+). Used car rates are typically 1–3% higher. Credit unions consistently beat dealer financing by 1–2%. Always get pre-approved from your bank or credit union before visiting the dealer — this is your negotiation baseline for the finance office.
Electric Vehicles
How does the federal EV tax credit work?
It no longer applies to a car bought today. The federal clean vehicle credit was worth up to $7,500 on a new EV and up to $4,000 on a used EV, but the IRS says neither credit is available for vehicles acquired after September 30, 2025. Leave it out of your out-the-door math, and check your state's program page for any state or utility incentive.
What extra fees do EV buyers pay?
Many states charge an annual EV registration surcharge to offset lost gas tax revenue. The state fee guides list the surcharge figure we have for each state and label it not verified, so confirm it with your state's motor vehicle agency before you budget for it.
Ready to check a vehicle?
Free VIN check: decode the vehicle and see open safety recalls in seconds.
Check a VIN Free